Skip to Content

It’s the question on the minds of Bachelor fans heading into Season 23, and one Bachelor spoilers can’t even answer yet:

Will anyone steal Colton Underwood’s famous virginity?

Colton Underwood, 40 Year Old Virgin Tribute Poster
(ABC)

And while our latest set of The Bachelor spoilers do appear to offer up an answer, we’ll need to wait and watch upcoming episodes to see how this all plays out.

In this first clip from the season premiere, however, a different problem arises for the suitors:

Someone keeps stealing Underway away… from them!

"So, I was just talking to Colton. So, that was great, but I got interrupted… by what’s her name," Tahzjuan says in this clip, which debuted on Entertainment Tonight and which features many contestants at the opening night cocktail party.

The Hollywood Gossip Logo

"Catherine interrupted you?" asks Onyeka, instantly aware of who Tahzjuan was talking about because she suffered the same fate at the hands of this competitor.

"I walked away, and he said, ‘Fourth time’s the charm?’" Tahzjuan replied.

"Four times? Everyone should get a chance to talk to him. Everyone! And I told her that," Onyeka says, before saying even more in a confessional.

Colton Underwood Cradles a Puppy
(ABC)

"What the hell! I can’t believe she stole Colton again. I thought we had a great conversation, we hugged it out afterwards and everything," she tells the camera, adding:

"But obviously she doesn’t care at all."

It sure sounds like ABC is setting up Catherine to be the season’s first villain, huh?

Here is the official promotional photo of her:

Catherine
(ABC)

And here’s a snapshot of Catherine chatting with Colton on opening night:

Will her backhanded tactics pay off?

We aren’t about to reveal right now whether or not Catherine makes the final four — but we do know the eventual Bachelor winner this season.

"It’s really frustrating because I have been waiting patiently and being respectful to all the other girls to get my time," Courtney adds here. "Catherine’s just being straight-up rude."

Check out the dramatic footage now!